Is Your Olive Oil Really Made of Olives?

Olive oil fraud? Believe it or not, many oils sold as “olive” are really just colored soybean oil! Ask yourself – Is Your Olive Oil Really Made of Olives?

Is your olive oil really made of olives

It sounds paranoid in a nice, safely-regulated by the FDA world, doesn’t it? I mean, if something says it’s olive oil on the package, it must be! If it were actually something else, that would be false advertising, right? And that never happens!

If only that were true.

When I learned there was a possibility that olive oils might not truly be olive oils, I was disturbed, but knew it might be true. This wasn’t the first time I’d heard of foods being labelled fraudulently – in a college journalism class, I followed a series on “honey laundering” written up in a now-defunct Seattle newspaper (I can’tcite my original sources, since the paper folded, but here’s another article on the same topic). Apparently, some of the honey in the grocery store that was manufactured overseas is actually just corn syrup – and even a few illegal food additives. Some of the fraud was discovered because the honey was being produced in countries where there isn’t much of a honeybee population, either because of the altitude or the climate.

How can you get honey without any bees? You can’t. It’s not honey – and even though some of the honey in grocery stores is legitimate, it’s so difficult to verify what is and isn’t real that I’ve switched to buying local honey only.

Obviously, I can’t buy local olive oil – so there has to be a way to verify that it’s really made from olives. I first learned about olive oil fraud from this cute video by MamaNatural. Fortunately, within the video, she also discusses how to identify true olive oil.

One option is to buy Californian olive oil, which is much easier to track, and much more pure. However, it’s also harder to obtain. I’m in the middle of rural Ohio – the closest Trader Joe’s (or anything like it) is hours away. I need a genuine olive oil I can find in a major retailer.

Thankfully, there’s another option: Look for the little seal on the bottle indicating that it’s certified by the International Olive Oil Council (seen in the picture below).


Sorry I couldn't zoom in closer - my camera has limited powers.

Sorry I couldn’t zoom in closer – my camera has limited powers.

This little seal guarantees authenticity – with more credibility than just the ingredients listed on the label (if you’ve read up on product labelling, I’m sure you know what I mean – it’s amazing how many ingredients *do not* have to be listed!)

I was happy to find that, among the dozens of varieties of olive oil on the store shelves, the certified olive oil was not the most expensive. It wasn’t the cheapest, either (the store brand of dyed pseudo-oil won that prize), but it was pretty middle of the road. And, since it came in a bulk size, I was able to save a little more money by stocking up on it and getting the big jug. If you can’t find real olive oil near you, there’s always ordering it online!

Just like any other food choice, it’s important to make sure you’re making wise decisions with your olive oil purchases. Be aware of the fakes - and look for authenticity!



Jaime W. (461 Posts)

Jaime is a Christian, a wife, a mom, a writer, an illustrator, and an aspiring homesteader. She loves trying to find new ways to save money and resources--but also save her time, so she can spend as much as possible with her family! !

Related posts:


  1. I heard about the olive oil last year and the honey recently. It’s disturbing, because it makes me wonder just how much of what I eat is actually what I think it is!

  2. Very interesting. I hadn’t put much thought into it! Thanks for the read!

  3. I had heard about the Olive Oil prob but didn’t think too much about it. I think there is one recipe we use it for – usually grabbing the coconut oil instead. I didn’t know about the seal — thanks! Next time I buy I will look for that. :)

  4. How crazy is that! I can’t believe companies can get away with claiming it’s olive oil when it’s not! Thanks for the info.

  5. I had NO idea! THank you for sharing this info on our Wellness Wednesday link-up. I’m going to be sure to pass this along to my facebook readers too. Now I need to go check my olive oil.

  6. Hurrah, that’s what I was exploring for, what a data! present here at this web site, thanks admin of this web page.

  7. hi!,I love your writing very much! share we be in contact more about
    your article on AOL? I require a specialist in this space
    to unravel my problem. Maybe that is you! Taking a look forward to peer you.

  8. I do not create a bunch of comments, but after reading a few of the comments on Is Your Olive Oil Really Made of Olives?

    - SlightlySteady. I actually do have some questions for you if you tend
    not to mind. Could it be just me or do some of these remarks look like
    they are written by brain dead visitors? :-P And, if you are posting at additional sites,
    I’d like to keep up with you. Could you make a
    list of every one of all your public sites like
    your twitter feed, Facebook page or linkedin profile?

  9. Combine the Red Oak firewood with hardwood lump charcoal. You can find more information on Biagi Beads at: Biagi Beads.
    The company now offers a wide range of temporal accessories on their website.

  10. Thanks for sharing your thoughts about movies streaming.


  1. […] c. raw honey (I *always* recommended finding a local source *if at all possible* because of honey fraud, but if you simply can’t obtain it locally, you can purchase it […]

Speak Your Mind